Eureka ! Info - Gap is Worst - Case Analysis ( Maximin ) in Disguise !
نویسنده
چکیده
Info-Gap is supposedly a new theory for decision making under severe uncertainty. Its claim to fame is that it is non-probabilistic in nature and thus offers an alternative to all current theories for decision making under uncertainty. In this short article I show that Info-Gap is neither new nor radically different from current decision theories. Specifically, I formally prove that Info-Gap’s decision theoretic model is a simple instance of Wald’s Maximin Principle, the most celebrated Principle in decision making under strict uncretainty.
منابع مشابه
The Info - Gap / Maximin Saga Continues
On numerous occasions and in many articles I have formally shown (proved) that Info-Gap’s robustness model (Ben-Haim 1999, 2001, 2006) is a Maximin model (Wald 1945, 1950) par excellence and that it is fundamentally flawed in the way it handles severe uncertainty. Furthermore, I have shown that the Info-Gap/Maximin connection is not strictly mathematical in nature. Indeed, the conceptual framew...
متن کاملWhat ’ s Wrong with Info - Gap ? An Operations Research Perspective ∗
Info-Gap is purported to be a new theory for decision-making under severe uncertainty. Its claim to fame is that it is non-probabilistic in nature and thus offers an alternative to all current theories for decision-making under uncertainty. In this essay I examine this theory from an Operations Research point of view. I show that: · Info-Gap is neither new nor radically different from current d...
متن کاملRobust Optimization of Recommendation Sets with the Maximin Utility Criterion
We investigate robust decision-making under utility uncertainty, using the maximin criterion, which optimizes utility for the worst case setting. We show how it is possible to efficiently compute the maximin optimal recommendation in face of utility uncertainty, even in large configuration spaces. We then introduce a new decision criterion, setwise maximin utility (SMMU), for constructing optim...
متن کاملOptimization and Elicitation with the Maximin Utility Criterion
We investigate robust decision-making under utility uncertainty, using the maximin criterion, which optimizes utility for the worst case setting. We show how it is possible to efficiently compute the maximin optimal recommendation in face of utility uncertainty, even in large configuration spaces. We then introduce a new decision criterion, setwise maximin utility (SMMU), for constructing optim...
متن کاملLinear Bounds on an Uncertain Non-Linear Oscillator: An Info-Gap Approach
We study a 1-dimensional cubic non-linear oscillator in the frequency domain, in which the non-linearity is roughly estimated but highly uncertain. The task is to choose a suite of linear computational models at different excitation frequencies whose responses are useful approximations to, or upper bounds of, the real non-linear system. These model predictions must be robust to uncertainty in t...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2006